.png)
November 28, 2024
A seemingly simple mathematical comparison has caused a stir in the world of Artificial Intelligence. The question of whether 9.9 or 9.11 is the larger number turned out to be a stumbling block for several well-known AI models. The incident, which became known through a social media post, highlights the challenges AI systems still face in handling basic mathematical concepts.
The discussion was triggered by a user's question to Alibaba's AI model QwQ-32B. Surprisingly, the model identified 9.11 as the larger number. This error was repeated by several other AI models, including prominent names like ChatGPT. The misinterpretation seems to lie in the fact that the models consider the numbers after the decimal point – 9 and 11 – in isolation and interpret 11 as the larger number, without considering the significance of decimal places.
The incorrect answers led to a broad online discussion. Experts suspect various causes for the mathematical difficulties of the AI models. One aspect is the type of training. Language models are typically trained to predict the next word in a sequence. This focus on linguistic structures can lead to the neglect of mathematical understanding and logical reasoning. Another factor is the composition of the training data. Texts from the internet, which form the majority of the training data, contain comparatively few mathematical problems and solutions.
Developers of AI models are already working on solutions to improve the mathematical capabilities of their systems. One approach is to expand the training corpus with specifically selected mathematical content. This would allow the models to learn to correctly interpret and apply mathematical concepts. Another approach is to adapt the training methods. By integrating mathematical logic puzzles and arithmetic problems into the training process, the models' mathematical understanding could be improved. Furthermore, special modules for mathematical operations could be integrated into the AI systems to ensure the accuracy of calculations.
The case of 9.9 vs. 9.11 illustrates that despite impressive progress in many areas, AI models still struggle with basic mathematical concepts. Ongoing research and development in this area will help to address these weaknesses and further enhance the performance of AI systems in the future. The discussion surrounding the mathematical abilities of AIs also underscores the importance of critically examining the results generated by AI systems. It is important to be aware that AI models are not infallible and their results always require careful scrutiny.
Bibliographie: https://www.reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/1emopvj/what_gives_with_the_whole_which_is_bigger_99_or/ https://www.gutefrage.net/frage/ist-911-oder-99-groesser https://community.openai.com/t/why-9-11-is-larger-than-9-9-incredible/869824 https://www.threads.net/@datsofelija/post/C9hLlE5ustI/why-911-is-bigger-than-99?hl=de https://www.aibase.com/news/10279 https://mindyourdecisions.com/blog/2024/08/07/9-11-is-larger-than-9-9-according-to-ai/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=48CM4Skmvkg https://twitter.com/stanislavfort/status/1813133891307229578